Everything else being basically equal--mileage around 90K each and price around 7K each, is there any overwhelming reason to choose a 2008 over a 2007 Mini Cooper? As far as extras go, the 2007 has a sunroof, but that's the only major obvious difference.

Otherwise, the cars are in similar condition mechanically and cosmetically, both with new tires. I've done a little research but I would appreciate any extra info.

I'm wondering if anyone has a strong opinion about which might be superior or least likely to break down...and of course, I realize that a lot of this stuff is subjective, but I also know that there are some motorheads out there who might have mechanical reasoning behind their opinions

Thank you in advance for any advice, thoughts, etc.

Sue

 

Welcome to MINI Cooper Forums, Sue! Are they both just the base Cooper and not the Cooper S? Both will be relatively the same. If they are just the base Cooper they will be more reliable than the Cooper S as the N14 engine those models do have their issues (timing chain, HPFP, oil leaks, thermostats, etc.). I'd also recommend plugging in the vins of both vehicles into this decoder HERE so you can see what different vehicle options they both might have. This can also help with your decision.

 

Do not take my experience into consideration; however, take Consumer Reports, which coincides with my experience:



Consumer Reports

Cars you’d be foolish to buy

Reliability, satisfaction, and test scores knock out these contenders

Published: April 01, 2015 10:15 AM
Worst used car: Mini Cooper S
When it comes to choosing a used car, you can put the odds on your side by choosing a model that performed well when new and has a great reliability track record. Of course, reliability hiccups can happen with any used car, but the Mini Cooper S has the worst history among all cars we have tracked over the past decade. Sure, the car is cute and delightfully entertaining, but year after year, the likelihood of having a problem that requires a repair is heartbreaking. And among the 17 trouble spots we track, engine major, engine minor, engine cooling, fuel system, body integrity, and body hardware have issues at an alarming rate. Although Consumer Reports often recommends skipping an extended warranty, the Mini Cooper S is a case where the investment would be a good hedge against potential problems.